The winner of the EISA´s Best Graduate Paper 2024 award is Aino Korvensyrjä from Friedrich Alexander Universität for her paper  The ‘Borders of Berlin’: West African protests and the coloniality of Euro–African deportation cooperation”.

The abstract of the paper:

After 2015, European states invested in deportation cooperation within the Valletta process to target ‘unwanted’ African migration. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork, the article examines how protests by West African migrants in Germany, accompanied by parallel actions in West Africa, contested West African authorities’ participation in German deportations. The protesters questioned the international legality of deportation as a moral double standard by referring to Euro-African borders as the ‘Borders of Berlin,’ drawn at the 1884–1885 Berlin Conference. It is argued that this unsettled the European policy concept of deportation as a ‘return’ to one’s supposed place and as ‘readmission’ obliging states, based on assumptions of equal national sovereignty and harmonious belonging. Building on post- and decolonial scholarship on borders and the international order, the article reads ‘Borders of Berlin’ as a situated critique of the postcolonial nation-state order by black and diasporic social movements. Arguably, this critique also proposes an alternative moral order by interpreting postcolonial African migration as a decolonizing practice of international law from below. The article also reflects on the fragility of the ‘Borders of Berlin’ as a decolonizing imaginary shared by ordinary West African migrants.After 2015, European states invested in deportation cooperation within the Valletta process to target ‘unwanted’ African migration. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork, the article examines how protests by West African migrants in Germany, accompanied by parallel actions in West Africa, contested West African authorities’ participation in German deportations. The protesters questioned the international legality of deportation as a moral double standard by referring to Euro-African borders as the ‘Borders of Berlin,’ drawn at the 1884–1885 Berlin Conference. It is argued that this unsettled the European policy concept of deportation as a ‘return’ to one’s supposed place and as ‘readmission’ obliging states, based on assumptions of equal national sovereignty and harmonious belonging. Building on post- and decolonial scholarship on borders and the international order, the article reads ‘Borders of Berlin’ as a situated critique of the postcolonial nation-state order by black and diasporic social movements. Arguably, this critique also proposes an alternative moral order by interpreting postcolonial African migration as a decolonizing practice of international law from below. The article also reflects on the fragility of the ‘Borders of Berlin’ as a decolonizing imaginary shared by ordinary West African migrants.

|

The committee comment:

Aino Korvensyrjä’s paper makes an important contribution to the study of bordering regimes by developing the notion of ‘Borders of Berlin’ as a postcolonial critique of Euro-African agreements on migrant deportations. The reviewers commended the quality of the theoretical discussion, as well as the paper’s methodology and engagement with research ethics. The author effectively demonstrates how ‘the radical imaginary of Borders of Berlin’ can put into question accepted mechanisms of legitimation of migrant deportations, with significant implications for policy and activism as well as academic debates.

About the Best Graduate Paper award

The Best Graduate Paper Award recognizes and supports the contribution of PhD students to the development of the field of International Relations. The paper awarded with this prize must be an original  contribution to existing debates in the field and offer a careful, convincing and rigorous analysis. The recipient will be chosen from the contributions of graduate students to the annual EWIS workshops.